Madden (2026)

Nicolas Cage as John Madden and Christian Bale as Raiders owner Al Davis in David O. Russell’s “Madden.”

Sloppy ‘Madden’ goes down in defeat

     In the autumn of 1976, I lived and breathed Oakland Raiders football and developed a deep affinity for the team’s quirky QB, Ken Stabler. They were coached by the roly-poly John Madden, then the NFL’s youngest head coach. After losing five of the previous seven AFC Championship games, including the last two to the Pittsburgh Steelers, Madden could feel the pressure as the Steelers once again stood between my Raiders and the Super Bowl. They won, much to my elation, then routed the Minnesota Vikings in Pasadena two weeks later for their first of three NFL titles.

      With that in mind, I was eagerly anticipating David O. Russell’s “Madden,” which begins with that pivotal 1976 game against the boggieman Steelers. Almost instantly, it became painfully clear that Russell, winless since “American Hustle” in 2013, didn’t share my affinity for the coach or his championship team. What he delivers is closer to the Raiders’ 1970s antithesis: the New Orleans “Aints,” which, like the flick, is a 98-time loser and arguably the worst the NFL — and Prime Video — has to offer.

    You’d swear Russell and his novice co-writer, Cambron Clark, were purposely fumbling and bumbling to nail down the No. 1 pick. Yes, it’s that bad, an all-out blitz of idiocy in which Russell flubs just about every play. This despite fielding a starting backfield of Nicolas Cage, Christian Bale, Kathryn Hahn and Sienna Miller, all of whom are left scrambling before being sacked by some of the puniest lines Russell has ever drafted.

    Cage is no help, guilty of numerous false starts in his clownish portrayal of Madden, a truly unique talent who seemed to excel at everything he attempted, be it as a player, coach, broadcaster and inspiration for EA’s wildly popular “Madden” video game. I met Madden only once during my incarnation as a sportswriter. But I can assure you Cage is no Madden, just an empty vessel stuffed inside a cheesy fat suit and sporting some of the most pathetic facial prosthetics since Weird Al in the music video for “I’m Fat.”

    Not for a second do you believe he’s Madden. I doubt he even took Madden’s ethos to heart. If he had, he would have spent long hours in the film room studying the man’s every trait and cadence before exiting with a solid game plan. That lack of preparation shows in every scene, reducing the part to an “SNL”-level impersonation so over-the-top he can’t be taken seriously. Ditto for a biopic that’s but a shallow compilation of Madden’s greatest hits as a coach, commentator and consultant, almost always within an arm’s reach of Al Davis, Madden’s best friend and outspoken owner of the Raiders.

     Unlike Cage, Christian Bale has Davis down pat, not just in his appearance but also his cocky New Yawk demeanor. Davis (“Just win, baby!”) is no less iconic than Madden, but Bale, in fairness, has it easier than Cage, playing a guy nowhere near as ubiquitous as Madden. Davis was more of an in-the-wings guy, whereas Madden was inescapable in the 1980s and ’90s, from beer and foot-fungus commercials to talk shows to his weekly gig calling games alongside Pat Summerall (Joel Murray) at CBS.

   Bale also has more experience tackling real-life characters, including Dick Cheney in “Vice,” Michael Burry in “The Big Short,” and, most memorably, Dicky Eklund in Russell’s “The Fighter,” for which he won an Oscar. With rare exceptions, Cage is too much of a ham to disappear into a role as thoroughly as Bale. With him, it’s often all surface, as it is here. Even his scenes opposite a very good Kathryn Hahn as the feisty but extremely patient Virginia Madden are flat and unconvincing. Of course, most of their exchanges are so poorly written they go in one ear and out the other, while Bale and Miller, as Davis’ adoring spouse, Carol, actually set off sparks. You almost wish the picture were about them and their unflinching devotion. It’s actually kinda sweet and provides the film with a rare moment of charm.

     Then, anything would be preferable to Cage, the proverbial bull in the china shop, arms flailing, lips always moving, making Madden look like a buffoon. At least in his scenes with Bale, he tones it down a bit. But it’s like fingernails on a blackboard when he goes head-to-head with the normally hilarious John Mulaney (beneath a hideous wig) as EA Sports founder Trip Hawkins.

    The only actor worse than them is the insufferable, painfully unfunny Shane Gillis as Madden’s fictitious next-door neighbor, Vince McGary, who, in Gump-like fashion, is improbably in close proximity to every Madden triumph and misstep. He’s grating, Cage is grating, and so is Russell’s sorry excuse for a movie. At least it’s mercifully short at 110 minutes. Thank God for small favors and inexhaustible needle drops of 1970s hits, no doubt inserted to soundtrack our rapidly depleting brain cells.

    See it if you must, but don’t say I didn’t warn you. You’d be better off watching a Power Four team pummel a hapless FCS opponent 72-0. Boring, yes. But at least it’s real. The only thing authentic about “Madden” is its inability to engage, a foul so blatant it should be repeatedly flagged for roughing the audience.    

Movie review

Madden

Rated: R for language throughout

Cast: Nicolas Cage, Christian Bale, Kathryn Hahn, Sienna Miller and John Mulaney

Director: David O. Russell

Writers: David O. Russell and Cambron Clark

Runtime: 110 minutes

Where: On Prime Video and in some theaters

Grade: D

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *